| Trophy | Award | Winner | Group | Play | Character | Year |
| shield -actress | Best Actress (under 12) | Rojin Aluntas | Ravenshead Youth Theatre | The Cat and the Fiddle | Child2 Mrs Maletski Jester1 | 2019 |
| shield -actress | Best Actress (under 12) | Rojin Aluntas | Ravenshead Youth Theatre | The Cat and the Fiddle | Child2 Mrs Maletski Jester1 | 2019 |
| shield -actress | Best Actress (under 12) | Freya Doherty | ELAPS Juniors | Cinders | Begonia | 2018 |
| shield -actress | Best Actress (under 12) | Jessica Das | ELAPS Juniors | The Badams Family | Fang2 | 2017 |
| shield -actress | Best Actress (under 12) | Ellie Wilson | Dean Hole Primary School | Murder at Haynes Manor | Mrs. Pinching | 2016 |
| shield -actress | Best Actress (under 12) | Millie Tatham | Peoples Youth Theatre | The Story of Cinderella?? | Step-Mother | 2015 |
| shield -actress | Best Actress (under 12) | Heather Quinn | Dean Hole Primary School | Yo Ho Ho | Pirate 1 & 11 | 2014 |
| shield -actress | Best Actress (under 12) | Milly Evans | Youth Peoples Theatre | Daisy Pulls It Off | Miss Gibson Headmistress | 2013 |
| shield -actress | Best Actress (under 12) | Erin Doherty | ELAPS Juniors | Let Her Rip | Peggy | 2012 |
| shield -actress | Best Actress (under 12) | Lydia McDonald | Dean Hole School | The Bourbons and Other Crackers | Henry VIII/ Announcer/ Harold | 2011 |
| shield -actress | Best Actress (under 12) | Ellie Thomas | Ravenshead Youth Theatre | The Spiriting of Burd Ellen | Childe Rowland | 2008 |
| shield -actress | Best Actress (under 12) | Charlotte Kirk | Ravenshead Youth Theatre | What Theatre Really Is | Number 1 | 2007 |
| shield -actress | Best Actress (under 12) | Sophie French | ELAPS Juniors | East Leake Today | . | 2006 |
| shield -actress | Best Actress (under 12) | Katie Roberts | Dean Hole School | Midsummer Night's Dream | Oberon | 2005 |
| shield -actress | Best Actress (under 12) | Jessica Cranmer | Touchwood Youth Theatre | . | . | 2004 |
| shield -actress | Best Actress (under 12) | Lorna Allison | Chatsworth Youth Theatre | Spacemapped | Sebastian | 2003 |
| shield -actress | Best Actress (under 12) | Lauren Baylis | Chatsworth Youth Theatre | The Games | Hare | 2002 |
| shield -actress | Best Actress (under 12) | Syann Hall | Touchwood Youth Theatre | Ernies Incredible Illucinations | The Doctor | 2001 |
| shield -actress | Best Actress (under 12) | Rebecca Colbourne | Robin Hood Youth Theatre | This is your Life Count Dracula | Waldo | 2000 |
| shield -actress | Best Actress (under 12) | Lynsey Fryatt | Palace Youth Theatre | Time Shift | Max | 1999 |
| shield -actress | Best Actress (under 12) | Kate Bonner | Touchwood Youth Theatre | Of Lice and Then | Head | 1998 |
| shield -actress | Best Actress (under 12) | Alice Kirkpatrick | Touchwood Youth Theatre | The Ass and the Philosophers | Little May | 1997 |