| Trophy | Award | Winner | Group | Play | Character | Year |
| Arcade | Runner Up of the Festival | Ravenshead Youth Theatre | Ravenshead Youth Theatre | The Cat and the Fiddle | | 2019 |
| Arcade | Runner Up of the Festival | Ravenshead Youth Theatre | Ravenshead Youth Theatre | The Cat and the Fiddle | | 2019 |
| Arcade | Runner Up of the Festival | Peoples Youth Theatre | Peoples Youth Theatre | Joseff Act One | . | 2018 |
| Arcade | Runner Up of the Festival | Peoples Youth Theatre | Peoples Youth Theatre | Our Day Out | . | 2017 |
| Arcade | Runner Up of the Festival | Peoples Youth Theatre | Peoples Youth Theatre | Blood Brothers | . | 2016 |
| Arcade | Runner Up of the Festival | Peoples Youth Theatre | Peoples Youth Theatre | Teechers | . | 2015 |
| Arcade | Runner Up of the Festival | Lace Market Youth Theatre | Lace Market Youth Theatre | Dust | . | 2014 |
| Arcade | Runner Up of the Festival | Kegworth Players Youth Arts | Kegworth Players | The Edge | . | 2013 |
| Arcade | Runner Up of the Festival | ELAPS Juniors | ELAPS Juniors | The Handbag | . | 2012 |
| Arcade | Runner Up of the Festival | Dean Hole School | Dean Hole School | The Bourbons and Other Crackers | . | 2011 |
| Arcade | Runner Up of the Festival | Lace Market Youth Theatre | Lace Market Youth Theatre | Much Ado About Nothing | . | 2009 |
| Arcade | Runner Up of the Festival | Lace Market Youth Theatre | Lace Market Youth Theatre | Ruckus in the Garden | . | 2008 |
| Arcade | Runner Up of the Festival | Robin Hood Youth Theatre | Robin Hood Youth Theatre | Blah Blah Blah | . | 2007 |
| Arcade | Runner Up of the Festival | Argent Youth Theatre | Argent Youth Theatre | A Dog's Life | . | 2006 |
| Arcade | Runner Up of the Festival | Lace Market Youth Theatre | Lace Market Youth Theatre | Grimm Tales | . | 2005 |
| Arcade | Runner Up of the Festival | Argent Youth Theatre | Argent Youth Theatre | The Lady's Bicycle | . | 2004 |
| Arcade | Runner Up of the Festival | Argent Youth Theatre | Argent Youth Theatre | Ghost Writer | . | 2003 |
| Arcade | Runner Up of the Festival | Robin Hood Youth Theatre | Robin Hood Youth Theatre | Sparkleshark | . | 2002 |
| Arcade | Runner Up of the Festival | Robin Hood Youth Theatre | Robin Hood Youth Theatre | Too Much Too Young | . | 2001 |
| Arcade | Runner Up of the Festival | Touchwood Youth Theatre | Touchwood Youth Theatre | Rabbit | . | 2000 |
| Arcade | Runner Up of the Festival | Robin Hood Youth Theatre | Robin Hood Youth Theatre | After Midnight Before Dawn | . | 1999 |