| Trophy | Award | Winner | Group | Play | Character | Year |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Whetstone Drama Group | Whetstone Drama Group | A Chorus of Disapproval | | 2023 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Whetstone Drama Group | Whetstone Drama Group | The Lady in the Van | | 2022 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Ratae Co-op Players | Ratae Co-op Players | As Long As They’re Happy | | 2020 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Whetstone Drama Group | Whetstone Drama Group | The Actress | | 2019 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Ravenshead Theatre Group | Ravenshead Theatre Group | Shock | | 2018 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Robin Hood Theatre | Robin Hood Theatre | One Man Two Guvnors | | 2017 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Argent Theatre | Argent Theatre Newark | Quartet | Great Welcome and CAKES | 2016 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Burton Joyce Players | Burton Joyce Players | | Consistency in the Welcoming Atmosphere | 2015 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Ravenshead Theatre Group | Ravenshead Theatre Group | Blue Remembered Hills | | 2014 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Orchard Theatre Company | Orchard Theatre Company | Ladies Day | Consistency in the Welcoming Atmosphere | 2013 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Orchard Theatre Company | Orchard Theatre Company | A Fly in the Ointment | Their Overall welcome | 2012 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Ravenshead Theatre Group | Ravenshead Theatre Group | Habeas Corpus | . | 2011 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Kegworth Players | Kegworth Players | Groping for Words | . | 2010 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Lace Market Youth Theatre | Lace Market Youth Theatre | Much Ado About Nothing | . | 2009 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Ravenshead Theatre Group | Ravenshead Theatre Group | Murdered to Death | . | 2008 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Burton Joyce Players | Burton Joyce Players | Allo Allo | . | 2007 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Robin Hood Youth Theatre | Robin Hood Youth Theatre | The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe | . | 2006 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Solo Theatre Company | Solo Theatre Company | Out of Order | . | 2005 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Ravenshead Theatre Group | Ravenshead Theatre Group | Come Fly with Me | . | 2004 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Solo Theatre Company | Solo Theatre Company | Are You Being Served | . | 2003 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Keyworth Dramatic Society | Keyworth Dramatic Society | . | . | 2002 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Edwinstowe Theatre Group | Edwinstowe Theatre Group | Seasons Greetings | . | 2001 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Blaby Drama Group | Blaby Drama Group | Habeas Corpus | . | 2000 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Edwinstowe Theatre Group | Edwinstowe Theatre Group | Rumours | . | 1999 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Ravenshead Theatre Group | Ravenshead Theatre Group | The Day After the Fair | . | 1998 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Arcade Players | Arcade Players | Edge of Darkness | . | 1997 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | East Bridgford DG | East Bridgford DG | Dead Ringer | . | 1996 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Keyworth Dramatic Society | Keyworth Dramatic Society | When We Are Married | . | 1995 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Penson Players | Penson Players | . | . | 1994 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Edwinstowe Theatre Group | Edwinstowe Theatre Group | See How They Run | . | 1993 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Edwinstowe Theatre Group | Edwinstowe Theatre Group | Noises Off | . | 1992 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Keyworth Dramatic Society | Keyworth Dramatic Society | . | . | 1991 |
| P&J Martin | Front of House Award | Arcade Players | Arcade Players | . | . | 1990 |