| Trophy | Award | Winner | Group | Play | Character | Year |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Paul Duffy | Blind Eye Productions | A Christmas Carol | | 2023 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Nottingham Arts Theatre | Nottingham Arts Theatre | Snow White and the Seven Dwarves | | 2022 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Nottingham Arts Theatre | Nottingham Arts Theatre | Aladdin | | 2020 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Lace Market Theatre | Lace Market Theatre | The Hound of the Baskervilles | | 2019 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | West Bridgford Dramatic Society | West Bridgford Dramatic Society | Thirty Nine Steps | | 2018 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | David Goatham | Bonington Players | Brief Encounter | | 2017 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Ratae Co-op Players | Ratae Co-op Players | Exit the King | | 2016 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Peoples Theatre Compnay | Peoples Theatre Compnay | Robin Hood and the Babes in the Wood | | 2015 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | West Bridgford Dramatic Society | West Bridgford Dramatic Society | Hayfever | | 2014 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | West Bridgford Dramatic Society | West Bridgford Dramatic Society | Ghost Writer | | 2013 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Peoples Theatre Compnay | Peoples Theatre Company | Macbeth | | 2012 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Lace Market Youth Theatre | Lace Market Youth Theatre | Oliver Twist | . | 2011 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | West Bridgford Dramatic Society | West Bridgford Dramatic Society | A Letter from the General | . | 2010 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Nottingham Arts Theatre | Nottingham Arts Theatre | A Midsummer Night's Dream | . | 2009 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Greasley Players | Greasley Players | No Sex Please We're British | . | 2008 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Keyworth Dramatic Society | Keyworth Dramatic Society | Tom's Midnight Garden | . | 2007 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Burton Joyce Players | Burton Joyce Players | The Eckersley Rising | . | 2006 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Bonington Players | Bonington Players | Pack of Lies | . | 2005 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Bonington Players | Bonington Players | All My Sons | . | 2004 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Bonington Players | Bonington Players | Ring Round the Moon | . | 2003 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Argent Theatre | Argent Theatre Newark | You Should See Us Now | . | 2002 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Edwinstowe Theatre Group | Edwinstowe Theatre Group | Seasons Greetings | . | 2001 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | West Bridgford Dramatic Society | West Bridgford Dramatic Society | Celebration | . | 2000 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Nottingham Theatre Club | Nottingham Theatre Club | Blue Remembered Hills | . | 1999 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Bonington Players | Bonington Players | Diary of Adrian Mole | . | 1998 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Arcade Players | Arcade Players | Edge of Darkness | . | 1997 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | East Bridgford DG | East Bridgford DG | Dead Ringer | . | 1996 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Bonington Players | Bonington Players | The Winslow Boy | . | 1995 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | West Bridgford Dramatic Society | West Bridgford Dramatic Society | Gaslight | . | 1994 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Penson Players | Penson Players | Round and Round the Garden | . | 1993 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Edwinstowe Theatre Group | Edwinstowe Theatre Group | Noises Off | . | 1992 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Botiller Players | Botiller Players | Midsummer Mink | . | 1991 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | West Bridgford Dramatic Society | West Bridgford Dramatic Society | Death Takes a Holiday | . | 1990 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Keyworth Dramatic Society | Keyworth Dramatic Society | The Importance of Being Earnest | . | 1989 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Botiller Players | Botiller Players | Hay Fever | . | 1988 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Southwell Theatre Club | Southwell Theatre Club | Crystal Clear | . | 1987 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | East Bridgford DG | East Bridgford DG | Who Killed Santa Claus? | . | 1986 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Botiller Players | Botiller Players | The Curious Savage | . | 1985 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Co-operative Arts Theatre | Co-operative Arts Theatre | Whose Life is it Anyway | . | 1984 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Newstagers Drama Group | Newstagers Drama Group | School For Scandal | . | 1983 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Penson Players | Penson Players | Half Way up the Tree | . | 1982 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Keyworth Dramatic Society | Keyworth Dramatic Society | Portrait of Murder | . | 1981 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Penson Players | Penson Players | The Secretary Bird | . | 1980 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Penson Players | Penson Players | Relatively Speaking | . | 1979 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Burton Joyce Players | Burton Joyce Players | Diary of Anne Frank | . | 1978 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Botiller Players | Botiller Players | The Heiress | . | 1977 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Penson Players | Penson Players | Yellow Sands | . | 1976 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Penson Players | Penson Players | Trelawny of the Wells | . | 1975 |
| Lallie McLaughlan | Best Presentation | Arcade Players | Arcade Players | Tom Jones | . | 1974 |