| Trophy | Award | Winner | Group | Play | Character | Year |
| Stephen Godward Trophy | Out Standing Youth Performance | Tilly Wishart | Nottingham Arts Theatre | Puss in Boots | Mia Pasta | 2023 |
| Stephen Godward Trophy | Out Standing Youth Performance | Hanna Fletcher | Bonington Players | Play On | Maria and Doris | 2022 |
| Stephen Godward | Out Standing Youth Performance | Tom Morley | Whetstone Drama Group | The Blitz Club | Harry | 2020 |
| Stephen Godward | Out Standing Youth Performance | Rhianna Trueman | Argent Theatre | Brassed Off | Gloria Mullins | 2019 |
| Stephen Godward | Out Standing Youth Performance | Charlie Newcombe | Ratae Co-op Players | A Christmas Carol | David Boy Scrooge and Urchin | 2018 |
| Stephen Godward | Out Standing Youth Performance | Alexander Tilley | Spotlight | The History Boys | Posner | 2017 |
| Stephen Godward | Out Standing Youth Performance | James Green and Adelaide Marshall | Lace Market Youth Theatre | Julius Caesar | Brutus and Cassius | 2016 |
| Stephen Godward | Out Standing Youth Performance | The Youth Team | Burton Joyce Players | Dick Whittington | Support | 2015 |
| Stephen Godward | Outstanding Youth Performance | Joel Walker & Annabel Redgate | Lace Market Youth Theatre | Pride & Prejudice | Mr & Mrs Bennett | 2014 |