| Trophy | Award | Winner | Group | Play | Character | Year |
| Jose Cook | Actress of the Year | Jill Morris | Robin Hood Theatre Company | Peggy for You | Peggy | 2023 |
| Jose Cook | Actress of the Year | Kate Hoyland | Whetstone Drama Group | The Lady in the Van | Miss Shepherd | 2022 |
| Jose Cooke | Actress of the Year | Laura Chambers | Lace Market Theatre | Consent | Kitty | 2020 |
| Jose Cook | Actress of the Year | Carrie Wale | Whetstone Drama Group | The Actress | Lydia Martin | 2019 |
| Jose Cook | Actress of the Year | Victoria Carr | West Bridgford Dramatic Society | Thirty Nine Steps | Annabella Margaret and Pamela | 2018 |
| Jose Cook | Actress of the Year | Michelene Harris | West Bridgford Dramatic Society | The Anniversary | Mum | 2017 |
| Jose Cook | Actress of the Year | Melanie Hamilton | Robin Hood Theatre | Gaslight | Bella | 2016 |
| Jose Cook | Actress of the Year | Val Petty | Prospect Players | The Importance of Being Earnest | Lady Bracknell | 2015 |
| Jose Cook | Actress of the Year | Zoe Lander & Abi Hemmings | Bonington Players | The Memory of Water | Mary & Catherine | 2014 |
| Jose Cook | Actress of the Year | Joanne Homer | Orchard Theatre Company | Ladies Day | Shelley | 2013 |
| Jose Cook | Actress of the Year | Jo Thomas | Bonington Theatre Company | Shakers Re-Stirred | Mel | 2012 |
| Jose Cook | Actress of the Year | Helen Foster | Prospect Players | Steel Magnolias | M'Lynn Eatenton | 2011 |
| Jose Cook | Actress of the Year | Donna Atherton | Prospect Players | Touched | Sandra | 2010 |
| Jose Cook | Actress of the Year | Kate Purdue | Burton Joyce Players | Cold Comfort Farm | Flora Poste | 2009 |
| Jose Cook | Actress of the Year | Michelene Harris | West Bridgford Dramatic Society | The Memory of Water | . | 2008 |
| Jose Cook | Actress of the Year | Beverley Saint | Nottingham Arts Theatre | A Street Car Named Desire | Blanche | 2007 |
| Jose Cook | Actress of the Year | Joanne Collyer | Greasley Players | Deep Blue Sea | Hester Page | 2006 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Sue Evans | Burton Joyce Players | Don't Dress for Dinner | Jacqueline | 2005 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Nicola Ellis | Edwinstowe Theatre Group | Educating Rita | Rita | 2004 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Kate Purdue | Burton Joyce Players | The Day After the Fair | Anna | 2003 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Margery Watson | Tollerton Drama Group | Farndale Murder Mystery | Mrs Reece | 2002 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Kareen Sims | Mapperly Mavericks | Harry's Bird | Debbie | 2001 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Kathy Saric | Burton Joyce Players | Remain Seated | . | 2000 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Kate Parker | West Bridgford Dramatic Society | Anastasia | Anna | 1999 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Carol Walton | West Bridgford Dramatic Society | Time and Time Again | . | 1998 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Myra Taylor/Margery Watson/Jan Jones | Tollerton Drama Group | Wyrd Sisters | . | 1997 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Maggie Burton | Burton Joyce Players | Straight and Narrow | Vera | 1996 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Janet Flisher | Newstagers Drama Group | My Mother Said I Never Should | . | 1995 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Kate Cox | Arcade Players | Pygmalion | Eliza Doolittle | 1994 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Sheila Hand | West Bridgford Dramatic Society | When We Are Married | Clara Soppitt | 1993 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Chris Keegan | Penson Players | Beyond Reasonable Doubt | Lady Metcalfe | 1992 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Hilary Edwards/Amanda Nowicki | The Albion Music and Drama Group | Daisy Pulls It Off | . | 1991 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Jacqui Marriott | East Bridgford DG | Wait Until Dark | . | 1990 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Amanda Bentley/Jacqui Marriot | East Bridgford DG | Wait Until Dark | Susy Henderson | 1990 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Diane Wilkinson | East Bridgford DG | . | . | 1989 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Janet Howard | All Hallows | . | . | 1988 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Jill Widdowson | Keyworth Dramatic Society | . | . | 1987 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Pat Monroe | Southwell Theatre Club | . | . | 1986 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Jean Mowl | Roclaveston Players | . | . | 1985 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Valerie Christian | Bramcote and Stanton Drama Group | . | . | 1984 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Anne McDowell | Southwell Theatre Club | . | . | 1983 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Barbara Tipton | Co-operative Arts Theatre | . | . | 1982 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Dina Buxton | Botiller Players | . | . | 1981 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Dina Buxton | Botiller Players | One Hundred Years Old | . | 1980 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Eileen Bale | Penson Players | Relatively Speaking | . | 1979 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Elizabeth Littlewood | Co-operative Arts Theatre | . | . | 1978 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Margaret May | Burton Joyce players | . | . | 1977 |
| Arthur Poultney | Actress of the Year | Audrey Niall | Arcade Players | The Chalk Garden | . | 1976 |