| Trophy | Award | Winner | Group | Play | Character | Year |
| John Barker | Best Supporting Actor/Actress | Kyle Keal | Market Harborough Dramatic Society | The Proposal | Natalya | 2014 |
| John Barker | Best Supporting Actor/Actress | Kyle Keal | Market Harborough Dramatic Society | The Proposal | Natalya | 2014 |
| John Barker | Best Supporting Actress/Actor | Matthew Huntbach | Lace Market Theatre | The Typists | Paul Cunningham | 2012 |
| John Barker | Best Supporting Actress/Actor | Ami Fitzpatrick | Spotlight | Carry Me Kate | Tash | 2011 |
| John Barker | Best Supporting Actress/Actor | Adam Guest | Bonington Players | Communication Problems | . | 2010 |
| John Barker | Best Supporting Actress/Actor | David Manning | Dronfield Players | The Fox | Policeman | 2008 |
| John Barker | Best Supporting Actress/Actor | Roseann Reynolds | Robin Hood Youth Theatre | Drinking Companoins | Bernice | 2007 |
| John Barker | Best Supporting Actress/Actor | Gita Bhatt | Avesbury Crickets | Grimm News - Scene 1 | Walter | 2006 |
| John Barker | Best Supporting Actress/Actor | . | Manchail Productions | The Man with the Christmas Socks | . | 2005 |
| John Barker | Best Supporting Actress/Actor | Jim Shaw | Keyworth Dramatic Society | The Big Cats | . | 2003 |
| John Barker | Best Supporting Actress/Actor | Lynda Precious | Keyworth Dramatic Society | Last Panto in Little Grimley | Joyce | 2002 |
| John Barker | Best Supporting Actress/Actor | Kathy Saric | Burton Joyce Players | What's for Pudding | Maureen | 2001 |
| John Barker | Best Supporting Actress/Actor | Maggie Burton | Burton Joyce Players | Caught on the Hop | . | 2000 |
| John Barker | Best Supporting Actress/Actor | Dilys Guite Players | Dilys Guite Players | Semblance of Madness | . | 1999 |